10 Tween Sleepover Party Favors and Gifts They’ll Actually Keep
Snacks, movies, and matching PJs? Check. Now all that’s left is adding the perfect touch — fun, thoughtful favors your guests will actually want to take home. These 10 personalized finds from J&J Designs turn any sleepover into a one-of-a-kind celebration your tweens will remember (and keep) long after the lights go out.
1. Personalized Makeup Bags
Link to Personalized Makeup Bag for Girls
Why it’s the perfect gift:
Every girl loves a cute, usable pouch. Personalized with her name, this bag becomes both a keepsake and a practical accessory she’ll use for cosmetics, school supplies, or travel. Items include cosmetic bag with monogram letter, scrunchie, rose petal soap, hair clips, socks, and lip gloss.
2. Custom Name Hairbrush
Personalized Hairbrush for Girls
Why it’s the perfect gift:
This custom hairbrush with name and cute charm is a daily utility with a personal touch. A brush with her name adds charm and value — something she’ll use often and use as a keepsake from the party.
3. Bestselling Etsy Pick Monogram Bag Charm Favor
Trendy Keychain Bag Charm Personalized Favor
Why it’s the perfect gift:
A small, charming keepsake she can attach to her backpack or purse. Lightweight, trendy, and fun — it gives your favor table a stylish pop.
4. Bestselling Bow Tumbler Handle Charms
Why it’s the perfect gift:
A personalized ready-to-gift matching monogram tumbler handle charm for all the girls to match during the party and in school.
5. Bestselling Blue Theme Spa Pamper Kit Goodie Bags
Preppy Girl Spa Kit – Blue Theme
Why it’s the perfect gift:
The cozy blue vibes in this cosmetic bag favor adds visual coherence to your party aesthetic. It feels cozy and thoughtful, giving Tween girl party guests a stylish, themed spa at home experience in one gift bag favor. Choose from deluxe, premium, standard gift set options.
6. Bestselling Birthday Cake Candle Party Favor Spa / Pamper Goodie Bag
Spa Pamper Goodie Bag & Birthday Cake Candles
Why it’s the perfect gift:
A cute spa pamper personalized gift set makeup pouch that she will love filled with cute accessories inside. The best birthday goodie bag, tween girl party favor, bulk party favor for pajama party, spa pamper party gifts, girly goodie bag favor, birthday gift for best friend, teen daughter birthday gift, and more!
7. Clear Stadium Crossbody Bag
Why it’s the perfect gift:
Stylish and functional. Many venues require clear bags, so this gift is trendy and useful. Personalization makes it more than just a clear tote — it’s her own. Upcoming Swift concert? This is the perfect matching clear crossbody bag for Tween girls.
8. Birthday Self-Care Spa Pamper Gift Box
Why it’s the perfect gift:
A deluxe curated gift that feels like a real celebration. Tween girl guests receive several thoughtful items inside one box— every piece becomes part of the memory from the fun sleepover party you created.
9. Bestselling Viral Preppy Pink Spa Kit / Makeup Bag
Spa Self Care Kit & Preppy Pink Makeup Bag
Why it’s the perfect gift:
The chic pink design plus the included goodies make it feel like a boutique gift. Perfect for a girly sleepover or birthday vibe — cute, practical, and photo-ready.
10. Custom Tween Jewelry Box with Name
Why it’s the perfect gift:
A keepsake she can hold onto for years. Personalization makes it her own, and every time she opens it, she’ll remember your special party. It’s decorative, functional, and meaningful.
Tips for Choosing & Presenting Favors
- Match colors or design motifs across favors for cohesion.
- Pair an accessory (like the jewelry box) with a small pamper item (like a bath bomb) for layered delight.
- Use tissue, ribbon, boxes, or clear bags to elevate presentation.
- Limit the number of favors to 2–4 for a polished, manageable look.
From custom jewelry boxes to spa kits, personalized favors from J&J Designs make your tween’s sleepover or party feel extra thoughtful. Guests will love the gifts and carry a piece of your celebration with them long after the lights go out.
Browse bestselling Etsy Pick options and customize your party favors at J&J Designs on Etsy and DesignsJandJ.com.
